4. Broken Monsters

By Lauren Beukes  

Based on what I can remember a year later, something about a female detective in decaying Detroit trying to solve a series of bizarre murders where the killer fuses the bodies of street kids with animals. 

The narrative switches between POVs of characters, going into the mind of the killer as his mind gradually disintegrates...or becomes something else.  It's later revealed he’s a homeless schizo artist.  The detective also has a fraught relationship with her teenage daughter, who along with her friend attempts to lure a potential online predator.  There’s also a transplanted loser-journalist who’s trying to revive his career in Detroit after screwing up his life in NY.  He hooks up with a dreadlocked DJ in the underground arts scene and becomes a local youtube sensation making ‘ruin porn’. 

All the characters somehow converge at the end with a confrontation with the psycho-killer who was able to transcend into some supernatural dimension using his demented art as a kind of portal.  Sounds like it was a crazy ride, right?   Mmm, no.

I first heard that Beukes’ niche was supernatural crime noir, which intrigued me.  I couldn’t find Shining Girls at Dark Carnival so got this instead.  So I really wanted to like Broken Monsters but several things prevented me from enjoying it.  I did not like any of the characters and the dialogue was often hackneyed and awkward.  There were some interesting descriptions of Detroit, which provided a cool backdrop of urban decay, but knowing that Beukes hails from South Africa, it became evident that she was writing about America from an outsider’s perspective.  

Moreover, there was something off about the writing style, which was workmanlike but lacked a narrative flow and a sense of lyricism that was needed in portraying lost or hidden worlds within a decaying metropolis.  As a writer, Beukes was just not able to pull it off. 

3. REAMDE

By Neal Stephenson

REAMDE was given to Olman by his BIL some Christmases ago, and Olman passed it on to me.   

It was a fun, but rather overlong, read that encompassed 1056 pages.   Olman had warned me that Stephenson can be overly nerdy in his descriptions.  I had thought that with this length, there would've been some interesting themes to explore, but there really weren’t any.  

REAMDE was just a globe-trotting techno-thriller adventure story where unlikely characters got thrown together, not just in the physical world, but within the virtual world of T’Rain.

Here’s a sample cast of characters:  a former smuggler now MMORPG entrepreneur, his adopted Eritrean-American niece, her cyber-slacker BF from Seattle, a Hungarian hacker, another Chinese hacker, a Hakka street seller, a Chinese-British MI6 spy.  Mix in Russian mobsters, Islamic terrorists, and Christian isolationalists.

I don’t mind super long novels if they're written well and enable me to immerse myself in the story and details, such as the wonderful Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell. 

At some point in the middle, I realized REAMDE wasn’t going to be a ‘great’ novel, so I started skimming over the overly detailed and sloggy expository sections.  I felt that even Stephenson was impatient to wrap up his novel towards the end because the final confrontation and shootout between the terrorists and the main protagonists at an isolationist homestead felt very rushed.

REAMDE would have been a great book to recommend if it had been pared down to half its length.  This was my first Neal Stephenson novel and it was obvious REAMDE was not the best introduction to his work (Snow Crash or Cryptonomicon might be better - both copies I have on my on-deck).

Here’s a very thorough, detailed review that aligns with my feelings about the book:  http://wrongquestions.blogspot.com/2011/12/reamde-by-neal-stephenson.html

2. As You Wish: Inconceivable Tales from The Princess Bride

By Cary Elwes    

1. Claire Dewitt & the City of the Dead

By Sara Gran

When I finished reading Claire DeWitt and the City of the Dead, I hadn’t posted my impressions of it at all (now writing something in 2025), and I could barely recall what the novel was about.  I remember feeling disappointed as I didn’t quite know what to make of it.  Even though it was a character-driven detective novel, the mystery part was probably the weakest factor, being quite anti-climactic when it was finally solved.

 

According to the blurb, P.I. Claire Dewitt “is a follower of the esoteric French detective Jacques Silette, whose mysterious handbook Détection inspired Claire’s unusual practices. Claire also has deep roots in New Orleans, where she was mentored by Silette’s student the brilliant Constance Darling—until Darling was murdered. When a respected DA goes missing, she returns to the hurricane-ravaged city to find out why.”

 

This was definitely a detective novel that focused more on the journey itself (be it physical, metphysical and/or personal) than on how the mystery got solved.

 

According to this blog review:

What is unique and disconcerting about Claire DeWitt is that she does not depend upon traditional investigation or procedure. Rather, she depends on vibes and seeming coincidence. She does not run down the list of suspects and evaluate alibis and hard evidence. Instead, she uses a lot of hallucinatory drugs and relies on leads received in dreams. She takes her cue from a (fictional) obscure French handbook called ‘Détection’ by Jacques Silette, from which she constantly quotes.

   And it’s the quotes that make this a compelling read. Not the detection. Which is hair-brained and unconvincing.

I can see now that the author was trying to subvert the detective genre, with mixed results (for me, at least).  However, a few years later, I unknowingly read another book by Gran, the effectively chilling, Come Closer, which balanced psychological horror with demonic possession.

 

I was planning on to writing a quick post for Claire DeWitt and put it in the trade pile, but after reading some reviews from readers who really liked the book, I may give it another chance (at some other time).  I also like the cover, so will hold onto this for now (I remember buying it new at Dark Carnival), as there are at least two more books that are part of the Claire DeWitt series!

 

 

9. Change Agent

By Daniel Suarez 

Ok, I didn't mean to read three books by the same author in one year, but Olman found this at the communal bookcase at his mum's apartment complex in Kits and quite enjoyed it. 
 

8. Among Others

By Jo Walton

Welsh-Canadian author.

7. The Alienist

 By Caleb Carr

Had this on my list for a while, but when I saw that Netflix had adapted this into a series, I promptly ordered it so I could read it first.

6. Ask The Dust

 By John Fante  

 

5. Freedom

By Daniel Suarez 

4. Daemon

By Daniel Suarez

 

3. The Wild Beasts of Wuhan

By Ian Hamilton

 

2. Ready Player One

By Ernest Cline

My BIL got this for Olman for Xmas.

 

1. Replay

By Ken Grimwood   

Amazing.  What a way to start off the year - a great contemporary fantasy novel with a great premise that was really well-executed.  I would not have read Replay if it hadn’t been for my boss Louis, who had originally lent me Dark Matter, which I really enjoyed.

 

When I later googled Dark Matter, I learned that Ken Grimwood’s Replay was a big influence on Blake Crouch.  When I was in Berkeley, I found two copies of Replay at Dark Carnival – one was a vintage hardcover edition that was $50, and the other was a 1987 paperback edition that cost several bucks.  I went with the paperback and must have started reading it not long after I returned to Montreal. 

 

Naturally, back at work, I ended up lending Replay to Louis, telling him that this was the inspiration for Dark Matter.  A fellow co-worker Mikael observed our exchange and mentioned how much he loved Replay, which seemed to cement the deal.  Little did I know that Louis’ life was about to get busy and that his contemporary sci-fi reading blitz was about to slow down quite suddenly….

 

Weeks and months went by.  Although he had started Replay, he never ended up reading it. I’d ask him once every now and then about his progress, but at some point I just stopped asking because it got too awkward.  Then the pandemic happened, 98% of my team have been WFH ever since, and I kind of forgot about Replay, or more like, given up on ever getting my copy back from Louis.

But fast-forward to October 2025 (I’m actually writing this review in November 2025). A Flame All-Hands was being planned for October 30^th.  I had only thought of Replay because I was writing about how The Midnight Library reminded me of a feel-good version of Replay. A few days before the All-Hands, I pinged Louis on Slack and asked if he could bring Replay with him, but mentioned that if he couldn’t find it, it wasn’t a big deal (it has been, like, several years since I first lent it to him!).  Sure enough, he found it right away and said that he had put it inside his bag so he won’t forget to bring it to the office on Thursday.  So I finally have Replay back and I can take a photo of the cover and put it up because I can’t find an image of this edition on the internets at all.

 

It's also been so long that I can’t be bothered to write a review.  I remember the premise and some details, but I may just end up re-reading it one day!